Story Comments
Posted by: Natureboy 10 months ago
This page is a permanent archive of the comment below and its replies.
To view this comment in the context of the full discussion for the story, use this link.
-
-
88%
hyperbola10 months ago
This comment is below the standard viewing threshold View It »
Even in Sderot, Israelis Say No to Gaza Attack
Reply
It has been widely acknowledged that Israel began a public relations campaign soon after beginning their bombing campaign over Gaza. As usual, they have had plenty of help. One example of this was Alan Dershowitz's article "Israel, Hamas, and moral idiocy" which ran in the Christian Science Monitor on New Year's eve. In a tired tradition, Dershowitz tries to blame the Palestinians for making Israel kill them.
...I've been to Sderot: just over a year ago in November, 2007. ... I saw the devastating effects of the missiles from Gaza. Even though there had not been a death from these rockets in recent memory when I was there, I was not surprised to find that the missiles had inflicted an incredible mental wound on the residents. But I was surprised to find that although the people of Sderot who I met wanted the missiles to end they understood that militarism would not protect them. The people I met with were not calling for war, they were calling for negotiation. ... Even an IDF commander I met told me, off the record, "The Qassams [missiles] are like stones, there is no way to stop them. The only way is negotiation."
Even more amazing, residents of Sderot are organizing to try to end the attacks. Read the text of this petition signed by hundreds of Sderot's residents which has been posted at the website jews sans frontieres.
Clearly not all people in Sderot agree with these views, as has been shown. But it's also clear that Dershowitz and other proponents of the endless war will always use the people of Sderot as the cannon fodder they need in the moment. The residents of Sderot are primarily Mizrahi Jews, poor and working class, who have been settled on the periphery to play exactly this role. As much as Dershowitz might want to fight to the finish, those in the crossfire just want an end to the shooting.
http://www.propeller.com/story/2009/01/05/even-in-... -
50%
Justice4All10 months ago
-
0%
Thinker2210 months ago
This comment is below the standard viewing threshold View It »
> ...I get angry when the same people try and equate any criticism of Zionism with anti-semitism.
Reply
There is no need to get angry. Usually getting angry intereferes with someone's ability to use his/her brains properly. It is much better to try and understand a bit better what one is talking about.
Here is some basic information about Zionism, anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism for your convenience:
Zionism is a Jewish nationalistic political movement claiming that the Jews, just like any other ethnic group of people, have a right for self-determination (a sovereign state).
Anti-Zionism, therefore, is a claim that UNLIKE other ethnic groups of people the Jews DO NOT have a right for self-determination. Anti-Zionism treats the Jews DIFFERENTLY from, say, Japanese, Russians or Arabs.
Further, the definition of racism is 'different trreatment of people having different ethnicity or skin color'. Racism against Jews has a special name, anti-Semitism.
Anti-Zionism is different treatment of Jews and is, therefore, anti-Semitism. Case closed.
-
-
loading ...
Ciera-Marie
Eagle_Eye
tehranchik
BronxBomber
Justice4All
alakazam
Dionys
Candida
blowback
dissent
tadair919
engineer
Post Reply
You are not signed in to Propeller.com. Please sign in to post a reply.