Story Comments

This comment is below the standard viewing threshold View It »

"You mean the journey to destroy Palestine, right? Began in 1947?"

No, the journey to destroy Israel.

"The extermination of the Jewish people happened in Germany. You know.. by Europeans."

The Arabs were their allies. But it still doesn't explain the Hebron Massacre in 1929 by your Arab buddies. There was no State of Israel then, and your hero Hitler hadn't assumed control in your fatherland yet. How do you explain that?

0 Replies

This comment is below the standard viewing threshold View It »

No Dionys, the Journey began as well in 1929 by the Grand Mufti in Jerusalem who had 100 Rabbis killed as well as 60 Jews in Hebron. None of those killed were immigrants, but Sephardic Jews who had lived in the area for untold generations. Palestine was killed by the Muslims after the conquering of the Holy Land from the remnants of the Romans. Since then, Palestine has been controlled by mostly Muslims, except for a brief period when Christian Crusaders had control, for almost 1400 years. Never in the last 1400 years of Muslim domination did a single conqueror attempt to establish Palestine as an independent country with an autonomous government of its own. On the contrary, they kept it under strict Muslim control, but gave it no autonomous control of its own. 2/3 of Palestine was stripped away by the British and handed to the Saudi Royal Family in 1922 with the establishment of Jordan, which I NEVER hear you talk about. Why is that by the way. Do you forget that 2/3 of Palestine just disappeared 25 years before Israel was established? And a Palestinian has never sat on the Jordanian throne. The rest of Palestine belonged to who? It never had an autonomous government and was never an independent nation, so who did it belong to that it was destroyed? The United Nations was the last sovereign government which was recognized by the world to have control over what was left of Palestine. They voted for partition in 1947, giving still more land to the Muslims. With 2/3 of Palestine now resting in Jordanian hands and another half of the remaining 1/3 being given to the remaining Arabs, that would be approximately 90% of the land called Palestine going to Muslim Arabs. So, who destroyed Palestine? Historically, over a 1400 year period, it was the Muslims. And history proves it. Argue all that you want, but Jordan still sits on 2/3 of Palestine. Add the West Bank and and the Gaza strip and the majority of the territory of Palestine is Muslim. The destruction of Palestine started in 635 AD, not 1947. You want to rewrite history? Be my guest. The Muslims have been doing that when it comes to Palestine since the early 1900's.

5 Replies

This comment is below the standard viewing threshold View It »

"I suspect the Palestinians would just like to be given back the land promised to them when all of it was taken for the Jewish state."

Keep repeating that lie. The Palestinian Mandate was promised to the Jews in the Balfour Declaration. 78% was lopped off and given to Jordon. The Palestinians should live there.

"it will be history made as the Palestinians have never had a nation "

"Keep selling the lie despite maps going back to the 1700s showing Palestine as a nation."

OK, name me a Palestinian leader before Yasir Arafat. Who was the first leader of the Palestinian people? When did they declare their independence?

0 Replies

This comment is below the standard viewing threshold View It »

If all of it was taken for a Jewish state, how come Jordan sits on 2/3 of Palestine? Did Jordan suddenly become a Jewish state?
"it will be history made as the Palestinians have never had a nation "> Of course they have a nation. It is called Jordan which was created in 1922 to be a national homeland for the Palestinians. It's just that Dionys and Justice like to forget that little fact of history. Jordan sits on 2/3 of Palestine. It's an historical and physical fact. Denying it doesn't change it any more than denying the holocaust changes that fact. The educated know the facts. The uneducated are always easily swayed.

0 Replies

This comment is below the standard viewing threshold View It »

Muslims want everything. They don't share. I've said it a million times, but no one has ever been able to show where a Muslim majority has ever voluntarily shared anything with a non-Muslim minority. Please Justice 4 All, show me where Muslims share anything voluntarily. They tried it in Lebanon with a sharing of the government between the Christians majority and Muslim minority (now a Muslim Majority). You saw what happened there after almost 30 years of civil war. What do the Christians have now? In fact, what do the Christians or Jews have in any part of the Muslim world? Ask a Maronite or Coptic Christian. They'll tell you- but you're not going to like the answer.

3 Replies